Quality Trumps Quantity in List-Building

One of my clients recently considered two options for building his email list to market his consulting services.

List-building graphic

One option was to offer an online contest for a free iPad. Contestants would submit name and email address to enter the drawing. My client would add all contestants to his email marketing list. The other option was to offer a free e-book with management tips for business owners, my client’s target audience.

Option one appealed to my client who thought more people would enter the contest for the iPad. He ultimately chose option two, though, because he recognized a fundamental rule of email list building: Quality trumps quantity.

Yes, he may have attracted more registrants if he ran the contest. You don’t have to be a business owner to want a free iPad. He might have gotten 10 registrants for the iPad contest for every one registrant for the business tips book. But more than 90 percent of those registrants would not have been qualified prospects for his services. Any time he spent emailing those people would have been a waste of time and resources.

By starting with a smaller list of better qualified prospects, he will spend less on his email marketing while converting as many sales as he would have with the larger list. In fact, he might convert more because he is not wasting time on those who aren’t real prospects.

The same principle applies to many list-building tactics. Do you put a “drop your card here” bowl at your tradeshow booth? Do you indiscriminately collect business cards at networking events without first determining whether the person could benefit from your products or services? Do you purchase email lists or scrape lists from business directories. All of these tactics can add lots of people to your list. Lots of people is not the same thing as lots of prospects, though.

Here are three simple rules to apply to your email list building:

1. Ask permission.

Whether running a contest online or collecting contact information in person, always request explicit permission before adding someone to your mailing list. Your list may be smaller, but it will be filled with people who want to hear from you.

2. Tell prospective subscribers what they can expect.

What will you send? How often? What’s in it for them. If you describe the benefits, more people will opt-in. They’ll anticipate and welcome your emails, and they’ll be more likely to open and read them.

3. Mitigate fear and risk…

…by reminding people you won’t share their emails with anyone and you will honor opt-out requests (and then always keep that promise). This, too, will lead to more people opting-in with confidence that you can be trusted.

These rules apply both online and offline. Describe the benefits of subscribing above the online signup form and put that privacy statement below it. If talking directly with a prospective subscriber, explicitly ask permission, state the benefits and describe the privacy policy.

You’ll have a cleaner, better yielding list that will generate more business with less headache and hassle.


Boost the Bottom Line by Bringing Back Lost Customers


A woman named Gwen recently sent me an email with the subject line “Give me another chance.” The plea caught my eye so I opened the email which was an appeal to renew a magazine subscription I’d let lapse. The email described new features in the … [Continue reading]

Beyond the Subject Line: Factors that Affect Your Email Open Rates


Our clients frequently ask us how they can improve their email marketing open rates. Most raise the issue by asking for help with subject lines. Write a better subject line, and more people will open the emails, they reason. No doubt, subject … [Continue reading]

Use Preheaders to Improve Open Rates


Tick. Tick. Tick. That's how long it takes subscribers to decide if they are willing to open your email. Tick: Sender Name Who sent this? Do I know or recognize the sender? Tick: Subject Line Do I find this interesting or … [Continue reading]

The Best Social Media Design Cheat-Sheet We’ve Ever Seen


Quick quiz... What's the ideal size for a: Facebook page cover photo? Twitter profile header? Logo on your LinkedIn company page? Video or photo in a Facebook post. Photo shared on Twitter? Yeah, me neither. Even if you're not a … [Continue reading]

New Study Confirms the Power of Content Marketing


We were glad to see a new study that underscores a marketing idea we share often: If you want to build your email list, offer free content in exchange for an address. Demand generation company Ascend2 surveyed 251 marketing, sales and business … [Continue reading]

Looking for a Good Idea? Swipe One!

My email swipe file

Mark Twain once wrote, "There is no such thing as a new idea." I agree. That's why I spend so much time swiping others' good ideas. Before you call the authorities, let me explain. When I see an email I like, I save it to my swipe … [Continue reading]

The One Question You Should Include in All Feedback Surveys

Management Expert Ken Blanchard (author of The One Minute Manager) once said, “Feedback is the breakfast of champions.” That’s a great quote. The breakfast metaphor reminds us that feedback is something you should actively consume. But feedback is … [Continue reading]

A Great Example of Myth-Busting, Personalized Curated Content


We were really impressed with this email we received from MarketVolt client Les Landes. We often encourage you to curate content -- reference others' works to make important points -- rather than creating original content from scratch. This email … [Continue reading]

Prospects Think B2B Marketing is Too Pitchy


If you sell to small businesses and you haven't been closing the sale, you might be pitching too hard. So says a survey of 401 small businesses from The Alternative Board that asked, "When evaluating a new product or service for your business, what … [Continue reading]